Molinism vs TULIP Part 1: Total Depravity
Among the five points of Calvinism—often summarized by the acrostic TULIP—“Total Depravity” stands as a foundational premise. In strict Reformed theology, this doctrine teaches that humanity’s fall into sin was so profound that no person can even desire salvation unless unilaterally regenerated by God. It goes beyond simply recognizing pervasive human corruption; it proposes an absolute inability to respond to God. Molinism, on the other hand, rejects that interpretation. While conceding the deep and universal effects of sin, Molinists maintain that God grants prevenient grace to all, making genuine response possible. The seeds for this perspective were laid throughout church history—long before Calvin—in both Eastern and Western theological traditions. This essay, expanding on the insights of Luis de Molina, will show that Molinism preserves Scripture’s teaching on human sinfulness yet avoids the contradictions and forced readings entailed by the Calvinist idea of Total Deprav...